Indianapolis Colts: 2026 NFL Draft Preview
How They Got Here
The Colts' 2025 season was a roller coaster that ended in heartbreak. Indianapolis started 8-2 through 10 games — their best start since 2009 — with Daniel Jones playing the best football of his career. Then everything collapsed. Sauce Gardner, acquired at the trade deadline for two first-round picks and Adonai Mitchell, suffered a calf injury against the Texans on November 30 and missed significant time. Jones, who had been playing through a broken fibula, tore his Achilles against Jacksonville. The Colts dropped five straight and finished 8-9, missing the playoffs for the fourth consecutive year. Anthony Richardson, who lost the starting job to Jones in training camp, made only two appearances (completing 1 of 2 passes for 9 yards) before suffering an orbital fracture in pregame warmups. He went on IR and is now seeking a trade — the Vikings have expressed interest. Riley Leonard and Brett Rypien finished the season at quarterback. Despite the chaos, Jones re-signed via the transition tag and remains the starter. Gardner is expected to be healthy for 2026. The window isn't closed — but it's narrowing.
Team Needs
Indianapolis enters the 2026 draft without a first-round pick after GM Chris Ballard made a bold midseason trade. On November 4, the Colts sent their 2026 and 2027 first-round picks plus receiver Adonai Mitchell to the New York Jets for All-Pro cornerback Sauce Gardner. The move was meant to push the Colts over the top, but Gardner suffered a calf injury and played just three games for Indianapolis. The Colts finished 8-9 and missed the playoffs for the fourth consecutive season. Daniel Jones — signed to a $14M prove-it deal — had a career-best season (68% completion, 100.2 rating) before tearing his Achilles against Jacksonville. Anthony Richardson lost his starting job, suffered an orbital fracture, and is now seeking a trade. Jones re-signed via the transition tag and remains the starter heading into 2026. With no first-round pick, the Colts must find impact players at #47.
Draft Outlook
Edge rusher is the top priority. The Colts tied for 15th in sacks (39) and lost Kwity Paye to the Raiders in free agency. Malachi Lawrence or Gabe Jacas would provide immediate help opposite JT Tuimoloau. Receiver is critical — the Colts traded both Adonai Mitchell and Michael Pittman, leaving Josh Downs, Alec Pierce, and Tyler Warren as the only proven options. De'Zhaun Stribling's size and speed would fill the void. Linebacker needs addressing after the Zaire Franklin trade — Anthony Hill Jr. would be a steal if he falls to #47. The Colts only have two picks in the top 100, so they can't afford to miss. Without a first-round pick, Day 2 becomes Day 1 for Indianapolis.
Top Prospect Fits
1. Malachi Lawrence
A high-upside pass rusher with ideal size and explosive traits. Jordan Reid mocked Lawrence to the Colts at #47, filling their biggest need at edge rusher after Kwity Paye signed with the Raiders. Lawrence offers enough play strength to contribute right away and can develop into a true starter opposite 2025 second-rounder JT Tuimoloau. The Colts tied for 15th in sacks last year — Lawrence provides immediate relief.
2. De'Zhaun Stribling
A size-speed combo receiver who fills the void left by the Adonai Mitchell and Michael Pittman trades. At 6-2, 207 lbs with a 4.36 40-yard dash and 36-inch vertical, Stribling offers dangerous playmaking ability. The Colts' receiving corps is thin — Josh Downs, Alec Pierce, and Tyler Warren need help. Stribling profiles as a Day 1 starter who can stretch the field for Daniel Jones.
3. Gabe Jacas
A clean and logical fit for an organization that desperately needs edge rush help. Despite signing Michael Clemons, the Colts still lack a true pass-rush anchor. Jacas' technique and motor would provide immediate relief and complement the athleticism of JT Tuimoloau. If Lawrence is gone, Jacas is the backup plan at #47.
4. Anthony Hill Jr.
If Hill falls out of Round 1 (possible given his dipped 2025 production), the Colts would pounce at #47. Indianapolis traded away Zaire Franklin and needs a MIKE linebacker. Hill's 249 career tackles, 17 sacks, and 11 forced turnovers at Texas make him one of the most productive linebackers in college football. His versatility fits Shane Steichen's aggressive scheme perfectly.
Draft Strategy
Without a first-round pick, the Colts must maximize every selection. Chris Ballard traded the farm for Sauce Gardner — now he needs to find impact players on Day 2. Edge rusher is the priority after Kwity Paye's departure. Receiver is critical with Mitchell and Pittman both gone. Linebacker needs addressing after the Zaire Franklin trade. The Colts have seven picks total (one each Rounds 2-6, two in Round 7) — Ballard must hit on his first selection to justify the Gardner gamble. If Daniel Jones stays healthy in 2026, this roster can compete. If not, the Colts are in serious trouble.
Betting Analysis
The Colts' #47 pick is harder to predict without the first-round context. Edge rusher is the obvious need — Lawrence and Jacas are the top options in this range. Receiver makes sense given the Mitchell and Pittman departures — Stribling offers the best combination of size and speed available in Round 2. Hill could fall to #47 if teams are concerned about his 2025 dip. The Colts are in win-now mode after the Gardner trade — expect Ballard to prioritize immediate contributors over developmental picks. If Indianapolis trades up into the late first round to grab an impact player, don't be surprised. They're desperate for talent.
Get live Colts draft odds
Ask Off The Bench for real-time odds on Colts draft picks and prospect props.
Colts draft predictions